Donald Trump, the former 45th and current 47th U.S. president, has recently proposed a controversial new immigration plan: a $5 million “gold card” visa. This program would allow wealthy foreigners to purchase permanent residency in the United States, provided they invest millions of dollars in the country. While Trump and his supporters argue that this plan would attract “high-quality” immigrants and boost the economy, the proposal has sparked widespread criticism.
Beyond its practical flaws, the “gold card” visa represents a deeper sickness at the core of American society: the pervasive belief that wealth should grant the privileged access to better opportunities, resources and rights than everyone else.
Under Trump’s proposed plan, foreign nationals who invest $5 million or more in the U.S. would be granted permanent residency, effectively allowing them to “buy” their way into the country. This idea is not entirely new; the U.S. already has the EB-5 visa program, which grants green cards to individuals who invest at least $800,000 in certain U.S. projects. However, Trump’s “gold card” takes this concept to an extreme, raising the investment threshold and explicitly framing immigration as a luxury commodity for the ultra-wealthy.
Proponents of the plan argue that it would stimulate economic growth by attracting foreign capital and creating jobs. Eric Ruark, expert on immigration policy and director at NumbersUSA, pointed out that such programs often fail to deliver on their promises. For example, studies of the EB-5 program have shown that it is rife with fraud and abuse, with many projects failing to create the promised jobs or economic benefits. Moreover, the program has been criticized for favoring wealthy investors over immigrants in more need, such as those fleeing violence or persecution.
Wealth Inequality and the American Dream
Wealth inequality in the U.S. has reached staggering levels in recent decades. According to a 2020 report by the Institute for Policy Studies, the wealthiest one percent of Americans now own more than 32% of the nation’s wealth, while the bottom fifty percent own just two percent. This disparity is reflected in nearly every aspect of life, from access to quality healthcare and education to political influence and legal representation. The “gold card” visa is a perfect example of how wealth inequality manifests in the immigration system, creating a two-tiered divide where the rich enjoy privileges that are out of reach for everyone else.
The Moral Implications of a Pay-to-Play Society
The “gold card” visa also raises serious moral questions about the kind of society we want to live in. Should wealth be the primary determinant of who gets to live, work and thrive in the United States? By prioritizing wealthy immigrants over those who come to the country seeking safety, freedom or a better life, the U.S. risks losing sight of its core values as a nation of immigrants.
This pay-to-play mentality is not limited to immigration. In recent years, we have seen a growing trend of wealth dictating access to basic rights and opportunities. For example, the college admissions scandal of 2019 revealed how wealthy parents were able to buy their children’s way into elite universities, while students from less privileged backgrounds were left to compete for a shrinking pool of spots. Similarly, the U.S. healthcare system, which ties access to care to one’s ability to pay, has faced scrutiny for prioritizing profits over people.
By allowing the wealthy to bypass the traditional immigration process, the U.S. is sending a clear message: if you have enough money, the rules don’t apply to you. Such an exception undermines the integrity of the immigration system and erodes public trust in the government’s ability to act in all its citizens’ best interests.
The implications of Trump’s “gold card” visa don’t just end at our borders. In a world where wealth inequality is already a major source of social and political unrest, the U.S.’ willingness to sell residency to the highest bidders sends a dangerous message. It reinforces the perception that the global elite can buy their way out of the problems facing their home countries, while ordinary people are left to suffer the consequences.
Moreover, the “gold card” visa could exacerbate brain drain in developing countries, as wealthy individuals with the means to leave their home countries are more able to do so. Given these same people are better able to afford advanced education, this could deprive these countries of much-needed talent and resources, further widening the gap between rich and poor nations.
Instead of catering to the wealthy, the U.S. should focus on creating a fair and equitable immigration system that prioritizes the needs of all immigrants, regardless of their financial status. This means expanding opportunities for refugees, asylum seekers and those seeking to reunite with their families, as well as addressing the root causes of migration, such as poverty, violence and climate change.
At the same time, the U.S. must confront the broader issue of wealth inequality that underpins proposals like the “gold card” visa. This would require bold policy changes, such as raising taxes on the wealthy, investing in affordable housing and healthcare and strengthening labor rights. Only by addressing the systemic inequities that allow the rich to buy their way to the front of the line can we begin to build a society that truly values fairness, justice and opportunity for all. Unfortunately, what we have already seen from Trump and his “super donor” far-right hype man Elon Musk is action against all of these values. Notably, the Department of Government Efficiency seeks to cut funding from everything that is productive, progressive or beneficial to America’s working class.
Elon Musk himself stands as the prime example of the new “pay-to-play” society we find ourselves in, having spent hundreds of millions of dollars in support of Trump’s election campaign in exchange for control over the new DOGE department. The department, under unelected Musk’s leadership and accompanied by unelected college-age teens, immediately went to work by restricting and cutting funding to government departments and organizations that were investigating Musk’s companies. By simply investing in Trump’s campaign, Musk was given the “keys to the city”, allowed to destroy whatever government activity hurt his profits, and left free to loosen government restrictions on his fellow billionaires’ activities.
Donald Trump’s “gold card” visa is a symbol of the deep-seated inequities that plague American society. By allowing the wealthy to purchase their way into the country, the U.S. risks further entrenching the divide between the haves and the have-nots, both at home and abroad. Instead of embracing this pay-to-play mentality, we must work to create a more just and equitable society, where access to opportunity is not determined by the size of one’s bank account. The American Dream should be within reach for everyone, not just those who can afford a “gold card.”
The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of The Cardinal Chronicle. Any content provided by our journalists is of their opinion and is not intended to malign any religion, ethnic group, club, organization, company, individual or anyone or anything
